The particular topic up for discussion in this instance is the problem of world poverty. In the ocean outside each lifeboat swim the poor of the world. This is what Singer sorely misses in his argument since he fails to consider the human craving for power and the satisfaction of the ego.
Zhuangzi, and Burton Watson. There is a lot of sense in what Arthur says: In his article, he argues that our first obligation is to ourselves and our posterity and that we would be foolish to let rich nations share their surplus with poor nations. He refers us back to the example of the child drowning in the pond, and says, now imagine 50 children have fallen into the pond and cannot swim.
He called this criticism Lifeboat Ethics. Both views reach a solution that gives the largest amount of pleasure and benefits society with a positive consequence. German philosopher Immanuel Kant would disagree. Being that this last solution provides the only means to survival, Hardin believes that the last solution would be the morally right decision.
Two such bright minds are those of Garrett Hardin and Peter Singer. For instance, if the poor are going to reproduce at and exponential rate in relation to the wealthy and their population growththen why should the rich have to tend to that ever increasing population?
Arthur disagrees with this. It is what many people would call a supererogatory act; good to do but not wrong not to do. The West lifeboat is in fact more like a party boat with lots of excess that could be given away without disadvantaging anyone on the boat.
The target we should be setting for ourselves he says is well within our reach, and a worthy goal. Thomas Hobbes argues that we all act in our own interests. Another issue that Hardin addresses is the growth rate of the human population, and how the affluent reproduce at a much slower rate than the poor.
An example is given of walking by a pond and seeing a small child who has fallen in and is in danger of drowning. The case for, or against, the poor is a difficult and morally charged issue. Anything else would be wrong, the fact that in rescuing the child we might ruin a pair of shoes, he says, is not a good excuse for leaving the child to drown.
If the West lifeboat tries to help the other one then they are going to become overcrowded and run out of supplies, as there is perhaps only enough room to save one or two people when there are hundreds drowning.
The 48 Laws of Power. He believed strongly in the idea of rights and desert. On the one hand, we have Garrett Hardin, who essentially suggests that we ought to let sleeping dogs lie so to speak.
Among the pond, 50 adults are picnicking and can easily rescue the children. For instance, donations of food to the starving definitely relieve the immediate suffering of those beneficiaries, but it also allows those families to have and care for more children than they would otherwise be able to- in other words more and more mouths to feed than the charities can keep up with.
Manifesto of the Communist Party.Two prominent authors were Garrett Hardin and Peter Singer, who wrote essays about human poverty.
They questioned whether to confront the issue of poverty or to ignore it. The first essay is "Life Ethics: the Case Against Helping the Poor" from the ecologist, Hardin who served as Professor of Human Ecology, and psychology today ().
This is the issue that is presented in the two essays – Peter Singer’s “Famine, Affluence, and Morality,” and Garrett Hardin’s “Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor.” While both essays are well written and make their points plainly, they support opposing sides of the issue.
Garrett Hardin, the author of Lifeboat Ethics: Unlike Hardin, Peter Singer, the author of. Unformatted text preview: The Singer Solution to World Poverty, he believes that the rich are obligated to aid the poor.
He argues that instead of going out for dinner, the money “spend at the restaurant could also help save the lives of %(3). Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor - Garrett Hardin What Should A Billionaire Give-and What Should You? - Peter Singer One of the most important issues facing the world today is the issue of the poor.
Lifeboat Ethics: The Case Against Helping The Poor – Garrett Hardin What Should A Billionaire Give-and What Should You? – Peter Singer Essay Sample One of the most important issues facing the world today is the issue of the poor.
Essays - largest database of quality sample essays and research papers on Garrett Hardin Peter Singer.Download